From: Tim S Kemp on
Dave Plowman (News) wrote:

> In article <1ikp8o7.fud1391v8ltcvN%steve(a)italiancar.co.uk>,
> SteveH <steve(a)italiancar.co.uk> wrote:
>> Also, although she's never used it for video editing, it'll do that
>> quite nicely, thanks. Because it's something that Macs have always
>> been good at.
>
> The premier pro edit system, Avid, is now PC rather than Mac based.

In fact there are only two reasons I can think of for owning a Mac, Final
Cut Pro and Logic Pro - two tools which are easier to get good results with
than the PC equivalents.

Everything else is turning or has turned PC. As you point out Avid has gone
PC, Protools has gone PC, Premiere and Vegas are PC. Photoshop etc, all PC.

In fact just checked (as not looked for ages) and Quark and Indesign have
also kept with PC based stuff too!



From: SteveH on
Tim S Kemp <news(a)DONTSPAMMEtimkemp.karoo.co.uk> wrote:

> Dave Plowman (News) wrote:
>
> > In article <1ikp8o7.fud1391v8ltcvN%steve(a)italiancar.co.uk>,
> > SteveH <steve(a)italiancar.co.uk> wrote:
> >> Also, although she's never used it for video editing, it'll do that
> >> quite nicely, thanks. Because it's something that Macs have always
> >> been good at.
> >
> > The premier pro edit system, Avid, is now PC rather than Mac based.
>
> In fact there are only two reasons I can think of for owning a Mac, Final
> Cut Pro and Logic Pro - two tools which are easier to get good results with
> than the PC equivalents.
>
> Everything else is turning or has turned PC. As you point out Avid has gone
> PC, Protools has gone PC, Premiere and Vegas are PC. Photoshop etc, all PC.
>
> In fact just checked (as not looked for ages) and Quark and Indesign have
> also kept with PC based stuff too!

Whilst some stuff that was Mac only is now available on both platforms
(no doubt aided by the Apple transition to Intel processors) - there are
significant advantages in running the Mac versions - namely the OS and
its stability / ease of use.
--
SteveH 'You're not a real petrolhead unless you've owned an Alfa Romeo'
www.italiancar.co.uk - Ducati 750SS - Hongdou GY200
Alfa 75 TSpark - Alfa 156 TSpark - B6 Passat 2.0TDI SE
From: DanB on
"SteveH" <steve(a)italiancar.co.uk> wrote in message
news:1ikpil1.sr4p0h1sq8r81N%steve(a)italiancar.co.uk...
> Tim S Kemp <news(a)DONTSPAMMEtimkemp.karoo.co.uk> wrote:
>
>> Dave Plowman (News) wrote:
>>
>> > In article <1ikp8o7.fud1391v8ltcvN%steve(a)italiancar.co.uk>,
>> > SteveH <steve(a)italiancar.co.uk> wrote:
>> >> Also, although she's never used it for video editing, it'll do that
>> >> quite nicely, thanks. Because it's something that Macs have always
>> >> been good at.
>> >
>> > The premier pro edit system, Avid, is now PC rather than Mac based.
>>
>> In fact there are only two reasons I can think of for owning a Mac, Final
>> Cut Pro and Logic Pro - two tools which are easier to get good results
>> with
>> than the PC equivalents.
>>
>> Everything else is turning or has turned PC. As you point out Avid has
>> gone
>> PC, Protools has gone PC, Premiere and Vegas are PC. Photoshop etc, all
>> PC.
>>
>> In fact just checked (as not looked for ages) and Quark and Indesign have
>> also kept with PC based stuff too!
>
> Whilst some stuff that was Mac only is now available on both platforms
> (no doubt aided by the Apple transition to Intel processors) - there are
> significant advantages in running the Mac versions - namely the OS and
> its stability / ease of use.
>

But for most people Windows is stable, and very easy to use. The only
people that have problems are Mac owners heh. I tried to post this using my
iPhone but whenever I hit send, it did the common crash where it just flicks
to the home screen. D'oh, bloody Apple OS heh. (it might not be an Apple
OS, I have no idea, and I was running a none-Apple app on it as well, it was
just a joke)


From: Tim S Kemp on
SteveH wrote:

> Whilst some stuff that was Mac only is now available on both platforms
> (no doubt aided by the Apple transition to Intel processors) - there
> are significant advantages in running the Mac versions - namely the
> OS and its stability / ease of use.

Except that there isn't. I have a HP workstation running Premiere, and an
Intel motherboarded PC also running Premiere. They don't crash, sometimes
Premiere gets a bit on top of itself but they're fast, reliable and easy to
use, and more people are familiar with Windows and its methods than OSX.

I use both, the Mac purely for Logic. Software is the driver, part of me was
tempted to make the second edit unit Final Cut Pro on a Mac Pro but when you
added up the numbers it made no financial sense at all. I have clients with
rooms full of PCs running multiple apps simultaneously, heavy ones like
Microvellum, Solidworx and Inventor, and they don't crash either.

Maybe the main problem is that people think a PC costs 249 (inc vat, monitor
and Vista) from Asda, and then wonder why it struggles to run outlook,
autocad and photoshop at the same time...



From: Dave Plowman (News) on
In article <1ikpil1.sr4p0h1sq8r81N%steve(a)italiancar.co.uk>,
SteveH <steve(a)italiancar.co.uk> wrote:
> > In fact there are only two reasons I can think of for owning a Mac,
> > Final Cut Pro and Logic Pro - two tools which are easier to get good
> > results with than the PC equivalents.
> >
> > Everything else is turning or has turned PC. As you point out Avid has
> > gone PC, Protools has gone PC, Premiere and Vegas are PC. Photoshop
> > etc, all PC.
> >
> > In fact just checked (as not looked for ages) and Quark and Indesign
> > have also kept with PC based stuff too!

> Whilst some stuff that was Mac only is now available on both platforms
> (no doubt aided by the Apple transition to Intel processors) - there are
> significant advantages in running the Mac versions - namely the OS and
> its stability / ease of use.

In a pro environment the basic operating system matters little since it
will only be running the one prog.

--
*Eagles may soar, but weasels don't get sucked into jet engines *

Dave Plowman dave(a)davenoise.co.uk London SW
To e-mail, change noise into sound.
First  |  Prev  |  Next  |  Last
Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6
Prev: Saab 9-5 HOT Aero
Next: 14CUX