From: Simon Wilson on
MrCheerful wrote:
> "Simon Wilson" <siwilson(a)nodamnspamn.hotmail.com> wrote in message
> news:esmc3k$3so$1(a)registered.motzarella.org...
>> Could anyone please confirm whether they think this is likely to be the
>> EGR valve? Is it possible to test/dismantle it to find out? The HBOL
>> offers no help.
>>
>> The car's done less than 40K miles and now it suddenly came up with this
>> fault. Coincidentally just after filling up at one of the 'affected'
>> Tesco's garages.
>>
>> I called a Renault garage, they say they haven't had any diesels come in
>> due to bad fuel, Tesco say it absolutely couldn't be them.
>>
>> I know the focus has been on unleaded, but is it possible that silicone in
>> the diesel could clog this valve up, or is it just wishful thinking on my
>> part?
>>
>> TIA
>>
>> /Simon
>
> silicone is the anti foam agent in diesel, so it is normally there
>
>
Dang.... it would have been nice to get Tesco to fund the repair :)

--
/Simon
From: Simon Wilson on
Brian wrote:
> "Simon Wilson" <siwilson(a)nodamnspamn.hotmail.com> wrote in message
> news:esmcgi$44b$1(a)registered.motzarella.org...
>> MrCheerful wrote:
>>> "Simon Wilson" <siwilson(a)nodamnspamn.hotmail.com> wrote in message
>>> news:esmc3k$3so$1(a)registered.motzarella.org...
>>>> Could anyone please confirm whether they think this is likely to be the
>>>> EGR valve? Is it possible to test/dismantle it to find out? The HBOL
>>>> offers no help.
>>>>
>>>> The car's done less than 40K miles and now it suddenly came up with
> this
>>>> fault. Coincidentally just after filling up at one of the 'affected'
>>>> Tesco's garages.
>>>>
>>>> I called a Renault garage, they say they haven't had any diesels come
> in
>>>> due to bad fuel, Tesco say it absolutely couldn't be them.
>>>>
>>>> I know the focus has been on unleaded, but is it possible that silicone
> in
>>>> the diesel could clog this valve up, or is it just wishful thinking on
> my
>>>> part?
>>>>
>>>> TIA
>>>>
>>>> /Simon
>>> silicone is the anti foam agent in diesel, so it is normally there
>>>
>>>
>> Dang.... it would have been nice to get Tesco to fund the repair :)
>>
>> --
>> /Simon
> The problems with fuel recently oin the SE, has clearly been reported as a
> problem with unleaded petrol.
>
> My car has a flat tyre, just after I filled up with fuel at Tesco's, can I
> claim from them? :)
>
> EGR valves do have a habit of sticking. In practice, they do very little
> good, and many people disable them.
> As long as it has stuck closed, then don't worry.
>
>
Thh check engine light is on, and won't go away, even if I clear it. I
don't yet know if the EGR is stuck (open or closed), but I have read it
can be pretty disastrous[1] if I don't get it sorted.

[1] Anything from inhaling all of the oil to a knackered turbo.

--
/Simon