From: boltar2003 on
On Thu, 01 Jul 2010 17:37:57 +0100
Cynic <cynic_999(a)yahoo.co.uk> wrote:
>Besides, if I understand the claims made by homeopathy correctly, then
>the multitude of properties would have opposite properties that would
>tend to cancel each other out.

Presumably then the glass the bottles the "remedies" are contained in has
to be specially formulated lest it negate the effectiveness of the snake
oil, sorry , homeopathic water inside?

B2003

From: bod on
Brimstone wrote:
>
> "Norman Wells" <stibbons(a)unseen.ac.am> wrote in message
> news:vv6Xn.86515$x15.34714(a)hurricane...
>> Brimstone wrote:
>>> "Norman Wells" <stibbons(a)unseen.ac.am> wrote in message
>>> news:6m1Xn.110852$aS3.9251(a)hurricane...
>>>
>>>> You stick if you like with your view that water can have a memory,
>>>> and that fairies may exist. What do I care if it makes you
>>>> ridiculous?
>>> Someone who tries to deny the existence of something when no one
>>> knows one way or the other is the most ridiculous of all. "Closed
>>> mind" is the usual term I believe.
>>
>> Do you think fairies exist then?
>>
>> Or can you rule the possibility out completely?
>>
> In the absence of any evidence either way, I'm ruling the possibility of
> fairies neither in nor out.
>
> Do you have any evidence either way?
>
>

Er, didn't he just say that he *didn't* have any evidence, either way?

Bod
From: Brimstone on

"bod" <bodron57(a)tiscali.co.uk> wrote in message
news:895ph3F3uiU1(a)mid.individual.net...
> Brimstone wrote:
>>
>> "Norman Wells" <stibbons(a)unseen.ac.am> wrote in message
>> news:vv6Xn.86515$x15.34714(a)hurricane...
>>> Brimstone wrote:
>>>> "Norman Wells" <stibbons(a)unseen.ac.am> wrote in message
>>>> news:6m1Xn.110852$aS3.9251(a)hurricane...
>>>>
>>>>> You stick if you like with your view that water can have a memory,
>>>>> and that fairies may exist. What do I care if it makes you
>>>>> ridiculous?
>>>> Someone who tries to deny the existence of something when no one
>>>> knows one way or the other is the most ridiculous of all. "Closed
>>>> mind" is the usual term I believe.
>>>
>>> Do you think fairies exist then?
>>>
>>> Or can you rule the possibility out completely?
>>>
>> In the absence of any evidence either way, I'm ruling the possibility of
>> fairies neither in nor out.
>>
>> Do you have any evidence either way?
>>
>>
>
> Er, didn't he just say that he *didn't* have any evidence, either way?
>
Where?


From: bod on
Brimstone wrote:
>
> "bod" <bodron57(a)tiscali.co.uk> wrote in message
> news:895ph3F3uiU1(a)mid.individual.net...
>> Brimstone wrote:
>>>
>>> "Norman Wells" <stibbons(a)unseen.ac.am> wrote in message
>>> news:vv6Xn.86515$x15.34714(a)hurricane...
>>>> Brimstone wrote:
>>>>> "Norman Wells" <stibbons(a)unseen.ac.am> wrote in message
>>>>> news:6m1Xn.110852$aS3.9251(a)hurricane...
>>>>>
>>>>>> You stick if you like with your view that water can have a memory,
>>>>>> and that fairies may exist. What do I care if it makes you
>>>>>> ridiculous?
>>>>> Someone who tries to deny the existence of something when no one
>>>>> knows one way or the other is the most ridiculous of all. "Closed
>>>>> mind" is the usual term I believe.
>>>>
>>>> Do you think fairies exist then?
>>>>
>>>> Or can you rule the possibility out completely?
>>>>
>>> In the absence of any evidence either way, I'm ruling the possibility
>>> of fairies neither in nor out.
>>>
>>> Do you have any evidence either way?
>>>
>>>
>>
>> Er, didn't he just say that he *didn't* have any evidence, either way?
>>
> Where?
>
>

"In the absence of any evidence either way"

Bod
From: Cynic on
On Thu, 1 Jul 2010 22:00:15 +0100, "Norman Wells"
<stibbons(a)unseen.ac.am> wrote:

>Then tell us what your position is on fairies, rather than evading the
>issue. Do you think they might exist, or can you say they don't? It must
>be one or the other.

I believe it quite probable that people have seen some sort of flying
animal or insect they did not recognise and called them "fairies".
Fairies obviously exist as a widely understood concept, and in works
of fiction.

The idea that small sentinent flying humanoids exist on Earth that
have the power to do magical things is however so improbable that I
discount it as a possibility.

>> You however made a very clear statement that you do not believe in the
>> existence of radio waves.

>Don't talk nonsense.

Oh, but you did.

--
Cynic