From: dsi1 on
On 2/14/2010 12:02 PM, Scott Dorsey wrote:
> In article<TKXdn.49867$5n.25372(a)newsfe23.iad>, dsi1<dsi1(a)spamnet.com> wrote:
>> I've had to replace calipers and brake cylinders in all of my cars. As
>> far as I know, it's not a good idea to do this and retain your old,
>> brownish, sludgy, moisture-laden, brake fluid. I'll at least bleed the
>> brakes until the fluid runs clear - it's the easiest thing in the world
>> to do.
>
> I have done this several times... and looking at what was coming out made
> me suspect that changing the fluid would have prevented the failure in the
> first place.
>
>> It could be that the high humidity over here is a factor but you're got
>> to be the luckiest guy in the whole world if you've never had to replace
>> the those parts on your cars.
>
> I have now a car that is nearly 25 years old and has the original brake
> cylinders and lines... and I attribute this longevity to my changing the
> fluid and purging the lines every three or four years. May not actually
> be the case, but it doesn't seem to be hurting.

I think you may be right about this. I don't buy new cars so I pin all
the blame on those negligent previous owners. :-)

> --scott

From: Ashton Crusher on
On Sun, 14 Feb 2010 02:15:06 -0500, Hachiroku ???? <Trueno(a)e86.GTS>
wrote:

>On Sat, 13 Feb 2010 17:22:12 -0700, Ashton Crusher wrote:
>
>> On Sat, 13 Feb 2010 14:49:59 -0700, "M.M." <nobody(a)nowhere.com> wrote:
>>
>>>My daughter's BF wants to change the brake fluid in his Corolla. It's a
>>>fairly late model...2005 or 2006, maybe 2007...so I assume it has ABS. Is
>>>there anything special about it on those cars? Can it be done without a
>>>scan tool?
>>
>>
>> Dang, I thought you were going to ask about all the blood stains on the
>> pavement from drivers killed by driving those things.
>
>It's amazing how you can still post after one left your brain splattered
>all over the street...
>
>But when one actually reads your posts, it's not such a mystery after all...
>

Your pain over the Toyota failures is noted.
From: Steve W. on
Vic Smith wrote:
> On Sun, 14 Feb 2010 09:00:01 -1000, dsi1 <dsi1(a)spamnet.com> wrote:
>
>> I've had to replace calipers and brake cylinders in all of my cars. As
>> far as I know, it's not a good idea to do this and retain your old,
>> brownish, sludgy, moisture-laden, brake fluid. I'll at least bleed the
>> brakes until the fluid runs clear - it's the easiest thing in the world
>> to do.
>>
> Be my guest.
>
>> It could be that the high humidity over here is a factor but you're got
>> to be the luckiest guy in the whole world if you've never had to replace
>> the those parts on your cars.
>>
> Never had a caliper or wheel cylinder fail.
> But except for a couple, I usually only have a car for 6-8 years
> before rust gets it. But they're usually 5-8 years old when I get
> them.
> Replaced a few failed MC's, which leads to bleeding, which once led to
> replacing a cylinder on one wheel. After that when I saw I'd snap the
> bleeder I just bled at the line connection to the wheel cylinder.
> Worked fine. Used that method a couple times when I replaced rusted
> rear lines.
> Never had trouble with caliper bleeders. They don't seem to rust like
> the wheel cylinder bleeders.
> I don't see not replacing calipers/cylinders as "lucky."
> But if they started failing on me I might consider that "unlucky."
> My experience is mostly limited to Chevys, but I never had a
> caliper/cylinder problem with my Ford or Chrysler either.
> Think I replaced the MC on the Ford.
> In fact, other than the MCs and a few rusted lines, the only brake
> problem I've had was when I did an emergency stop in my VW squareback
> shortly after I bought it.
> Slewed real bad. When I got home I crawled under the back axle and
> found....a snapped off bleeder on the passenger side wheel.
> No, the EZ-Out didn't work, but cylinders are cheap.
>
>> The trend these days is to sell loaded calipers to guys servicing brakes
>> which could be seen as a marketing ploy. However, I've bought these sets
>> if I thought my seals were leaking, the savings in time and hassle seems
>> worth the price - but I could be wrong. :-)
>>
> What do you mean "thought my seals were leaking?"
> What kind of cars are you talking about?
> Should be obvious if the seals are leaking or not.
> I've seen "damp" boots on wheel cylinders - which I ignore - but never
> any sign of leaking on calipers.
> Not saying it doesn't happen, just that it hasn't on my cars.
> BTW, I don't race my cars. Just abuse them normally.
> Let me toss this in, since we're talking about bleeding.
> My brother, who was a pro mech, speculates that most MC failures are
> due to bleeding, where the bleeder moves the piston farther than it
> normally goes, and screws the seals.
> Makes sense, but I'm no expert.
> I have seen mention of using a "stop" behind the pedal to prevent
> this. I never used one when I bled brakes, but it might be a good
> idea.
> Or use a pressure bleeder to avoid the pedal action altogether.
>
> --Vic
>

You must live in an area that usually doesn't get snow/salt on the
roads. In this area if you buy a 5 year old vehicle and keep it 5 years,
you WILL be replacing wheel cylinders, calipers, and lines. Salt just
LOVES to eat them up.

I'm to the point now that I just plan ahead and pre-bend new tubes when
the originals are in good shape.

I'd pay extra for a vehicle equipped with quality stainless lines (fuel,
brake and emissions) One less headache...

--
Steve W.
From: Nate Nagel on
On 02/14/2010 10:27 PM, Steve W. wrote:
> Vic Smith wrote:
>> On Sun, 14 Feb 2010 09:00:01 -1000, dsi1<dsi1(a)spamnet.com> wrote:
>>
>>> I've had to replace calipers and brake cylinders in all of my cars. As
>>> far as I know, it's not a good idea to do this and retain your old,
>>> brownish, sludgy, moisture-laden, brake fluid. I'll at least bleed the
>>> brakes until the fluid runs clear - it's the easiest thing in the world
>>> to do.
>>>
>> Be my guest.
>>
>>> It could be that the high humidity over here is a factor but you're got
>>> to be the luckiest guy in the whole world if you've never had to replace
>>> the those parts on your cars.
>>>
>> Never had a caliper or wheel cylinder fail.
>> But except for a couple, I usually only have a car for 6-8 years
>> before rust gets it. But they're usually 5-8 years old when I get
>> them.
>> Replaced a few failed MC's, which leads to bleeding, which once led to
>> replacing a cylinder on one wheel. After that when I saw I'd snap the
>> bleeder I just bled at the line connection to the wheel cylinder.
>> Worked fine. Used that method a couple times when I replaced rusted
>> rear lines.
>> Never had trouble with caliper bleeders. They don't seem to rust like
>> the wheel cylinder bleeders.
>> I don't see not replacing calipers/cylinders as "lucky."
>> But if they started failing on me I might consider that "unlucky."
>> My experience is mostly limited to Chevys, but I never had a
>> caliper/cylinder problem with my Ford or Chrysler either.
>> Think I replaced the MC on the Ford.
>> In fact, other than the MCs and a few rusted lines, the only brake
>> problem I've had was when I did an emergency stop in my VW squareback
>> shortly after I bought it.
>> Slewed real bad. When I got home I crawled under the back axle and
>> found....a snapped off bleeder on the passenger side wheel.
>> No, the EZ-Out didn't work, but cylinders are cheap.
>>
>>> The trend these days is to sell loaded calipers to guys servicing brakes
>>> which could be seen as a marketing ploy. However, I've bought these sets
>>> if I thought my seals were leaking, the savings in time and hassle seems
>>> worth the price - but I could be wrong. :-)
>>>
>> What do you mean "thought my seals were leaking?"
>> What kind of cars are you talking about?
>> Should be obvious if the seals are leaking or not.
>> I've seen "damp" boots on wheel cylinders - which I ignore - but never
>> any sign of leaking on calipers.
>> Not saying it doesn't happen, just that it hasn't on my cars.
>> BTW, I don't race my cars. Just abuse them normally.
>> Let me toss this in, since we're talking about bleeding.
>> My brother, who was a pro mech, speculates that most MC failures are
>> due to bleeding, where the bleeder moves the piston farther than it
>> normally goes, and screws the seals.
>> Makes sense, but I'm no expert.
>> I have seen mention of using a "stop" behind the pedal to prevent
>> this. I never used one when I bled brakes, but it might be a good
>> idea.
>> Or use a pressure bleeder to avoid the pedal action altogether.
>>
>> --Vic
>>
>
> You must live in an area that usually doesn't get snow/salt on the
> roads. In this area if you buy a 5 year old vehicle and keep it 5 years,
> you WILL be replacing wheel cylinders, calipers, and lines. Salt just
> LOVES to eat them up.
>
> I'm to the point now that I just plan ahead and pre-bend new tubes when
> the originals are in good shape.
>
> I'd pay extra for a vehicle equipped with quality stainless lines (fuel,
> brake and emissions) One less headache...
>

if you have a keeper, why not remove your lines and send them to classic
or inline for a pattern before they're completely hosed? Obviously
you'd have to do this around a vacation or something, because they're
not going to get your shiny new stainless lines back to you the next day.

just a thought...

I dunno where you live but it sounds horrific. I grew up in western PA
and even there I really only remember two vehicles having to replace
hard lines, and both were fairly elderly.

nate

--
replace "roosters" with "cox" to reply.
http://members.cox.net/njnagel
From: cuhulin on
Rusty brake cylinder problem? The way White Post Restorations does it.
http://www.whitepost.com/brake.html
cuhulin