From: boltar2003 on
On Thu, 01 Jul 2010 17:07:20 +0100
Paul <paul23023(a)hotmail.com> wrote:
>Ian Jackson wrote:
>> In message <hgcp26tp0r29iftjsq25j6i8fftc5hf988(a)4ax.com>, Cynic
>> <cynic_999(a)yahoo.co.uk> writes
>>>
>>
>>> If I were able to explain how such a mechanism worked and exactly how
>>> it behaved, it would not be unknown, would it?
>>>
>> If homeopathy really worked, a glass or two of river water, taken from
>> well downstream (preferably near where it enters the sea), would
>> probably contain sufficient infinitely diluted remedies ('second-hand',
>> of course) to cure all illnesses know to man - and even some which man
>> doesn't even know of.
>
>lol, doesn't it need to be stirred with a special stick?

Probably needs a couple of chakra crystals dipped in it and some whale
song played nearby just to be 100% sure.

B2003

From: Ian Jackson on
In message <893sq2FmohU1(a)mid.individual.net>, Paul
<paul23023(a)hotmail.com> writes
>Ian Jackson wrote:
>> In message <hgcp26tp0r29iftjsq25j6i8fftc5hf988(a)4ax.com>, Cynic
>><cynic_999(a)yahoo.co.uk> writes
>>>
>>
>>> If I were able to explain how such a mechanism worked and exactly
>>>how
>>> it behaved, it would not be unknown, would it?
>>>
>> If homeopathy really worked, a glass or two of river water, taken
>>from well downstream (preferably near where it enters the sea), would
>>probably contain sufficient infinitely diluted remedies
>>('second-hand', of course) to cure all illnesses know to man - and
>>even some which man doesn't even know of.
>
>lol, doesn't it need to be stirred with a special stick?

Of course not! You are just being silly.
Any ordinary, run-of-the-mill sterilised stick will do, provided you
stir the water with the correct number of rotations (so many turns
clockwise, followed immediately by so many turns anticlockwise).
--
Ian
From: Norman Wells on
Cynic wrote:
> On Thu, 1 Jul 2010 15:11:10 +0100, "Norman Wells"
> <stibbons(a)unseen.ac.am> wrote:
>
>> You stick if you like with your view that water can have a memory,
>> and that fairies may exist. What do I care if it makes you
>> ridiculous?
>
> And you may stick with your view that radio waves are an impossibility
> and silicon chips cannot possibly store information. What do I care
> if it makes you ridiculous?

Yes. The difference is that I have never held such views, nor put them
forward.

From: Cynic on
On Thu, 1 Jul 2010 17:04:04 +0100, Ian Jackson
<ianREMOVETHISjackson(a)g3ohx.demon.co.uk> wrote:

>>If I were able to explain how such a mechanism worked and exactly how
>>it behaved, it would not be unknown, would it?
>>
>If homeopathy really worked, a glass or two of river water, taken from
>well downstream (preferably near where it enters the sea), would
>probably contain sufficient infinitely diluted remedies ('second-hand',
>of course) to cure all illnesses know to man - and even some which man
>doesn't even know of.

Faulty logic. If taking two asprin would be beneficial to your
health, it does not follow that taking the whole bottle would be even
better!

Besides, if I understand the claims made by homeopathy correctly, then
the multitude of properties would have opposite properties that would
tend to cancel each other out.

--
Cynic


From: Cynic on
On Thu, 1 Jul 2010 17:30:12 +0100, "Norman Wells"
<stibbons(a)unseen.ac.am> wrote:

>>> You stick if you like with your view that water can have a memory,
>>> and that fairies may exist. What do I care if it makes you
>>> ridiculous?
>>
>> And you may stick with your view that radio waves are an impossibility
>> and silicon chips cannot possibly store information. What do I care
>> if it makes you ridiculous?
>
>Yes. The difference is that I have never held such views, nor put them
>forward.

Why do you believe there is any difference?

--
Cynic